Showing posts with label Concussion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Concussion. Show all posts

Friday, February 5, 2016

NFL concussion data

The NFL released their concussion data and reported a 58% increase in the number of concussions sustained this football season. There was also an increase in the number of head to head collisions that led to a concussion. While it is good that athletes are being screened and picked up at a higher level, it is concerning that rule changes to limit head to head contact do not seem to working as of yet.

The new standard in youth football is to teach heads up contact. This means that athletes look at their opponent, engage their neck muscles and use their chest and shoulders to initiate contact. This tackling style has led to a decreased incidence of concussion in youth athletes. I think this focus on tackling is fantastic and I am hoping that it changes how athletes tackle when moving up their playing career. I am concerned, however, that professionals are not modeling proper tackling behavior.

If professionals do not use proper technique, how can we expect younger athletes to do so? When they watch their idols playing every weekend and using their head to make contact how can we tell them on Monday that they did it wrong? For concussion education and tackling technique to make an impact it has to be both a top down and bottom up approach. The rules need to be upheld and proper technique needs to be stressed in order for substantial change to occur. I fear that if we don't stress the importance of technique at every level that we will continue to see head to head contacts and concussion rates that don't change over time.


Thursday, November 5, 2015

Recommendations on Tackling in Youth Football

 
The American Academy of Pediatrics released a study looking at tackling in football. The authors of the study performed a literature review looking at the mechanisms of head, neck and catastrophic injury in football.
 
Not surprisingly, the act of performing a tackle, or being tackled, is a leading mechanism of injury in football for head and neck injuries, catastrophic injuries and other serious injuries. One of the leading causes of concussion in youth and high school sports is head to head contact. The main recommendation in this area is to continually stress proper tackling technique and educating players and coaches on the importance of keeping their heads up and making contact with their shoulder pads, thus reducing the mechanism of head to head contact.
 
The authors summarize their findings of tackling in football by exploring the idea of limiting contact in practice to reduce the overall occurrence of head contact throughout the season, but do point out that it is not fully known how much of an impact this will make. They also discuss increasing the age at which players initiate contact and the possibility of non-contact leagues. This would allow those that are interested in playing, but are concerned for head injuries, an outlet to enjoy the game with a decreased injury risk.
 
As athletic trainers, we play a key role in the recommendations made by the authors. The last two points that they recommend on tackling in youth football are to institute neck strengthening programs and have an athletic trainer on hand for contests. We have the ability to educate coaches, athletes and administrations on the risk of head injury in football (and sports in general) and the implementation of programs to reduce to the risk, including strengthening and skills based technical training. Having an athletic trainer available to athletes allows injuries to be detected and treated earlier.
 
While the risk of injury will not be eliminated in sports, we can hopefully continue to make progress with our educational material to keep all of our athletes healthy and active.

Thursday, July 23, 2015

Concussion research



The news on concussions keeps on coming. It is quite the hot study topic these days, and for good reason; we do not know as much about their prevention and treatment as we should.

Stanford researchers have been criticizing the helmet tests that determine their safety by pointing out the fact that they may not be accurately testing for concussions. Helmets do a great job at dissipating force that can cause blunt force trauma and fractures, but they are not capable of decelerating the brain on the brain stem. The researchers looked at the cause of injury and noticed there was a rotational force component that was not being accounted for in standard tests and they recommend that future tests take this into consideration. While this is a great summary of the causes of concussions, I am still skeptical at the ability of a helmet to effectively control the acceleration and deceleration of the brain. I think the biggest factor in preventing concussions is to properly train kids how to play.

This is also born out in another study that looked at the causes of concussions in soccer. Heading the ball is typically blamed for the injuries sustained, but the actual results show that individuals are more likely to have a concussion in a collision. An aggressive play style increases the risk over heading alone. Along with player education and training in football, soccer athletes should be taught how to protect themselves and referees should work to ensure that the play stays within the laws of the game. Keeping the game under control can help to decrease the risk of sustaining a head injury.

When an athlete does suffer a concussion, it is not fully clear why some athletes heal faster than others, until now. Researchers looked at the brains of children with head injuries and compared them to their non-injured counterparts and noticed that those who have a head injury have slower electrical activity. This may be a result of damage the coating that surrounds nerve fibers and aids in conduction. This lining may be injured in a concussion and may help explain why some athletes take longer to heal. When this lining is damaged, nerve impulses are not effectively transmitted which can cause some of the common symptoms related to a concussion such as headaches, confusion, vision trouble and difficulty concentrating. They may not return to normal until this lining is healed. 

Overall, lots of interesting new news on the head injury front. Hopefully, in time we will have a better picture of what is happening when the brain is injured so we can effectively work to decrease injuries and improve healing.

Tuesday, June 9, 2015

Concussion policy

With a lot of States adopting a mandatory concussion policy, schools are putting policies in place, which is great, unless you don’t actually follow them.

 

Writing down policies and procedures is essential to think through handling injuries and action plans, but they are not useful, or legally defensible, if they are not used. When you take the time to craft a policy and educate everyone in how to implement it, it needs to be acted upon. This can sometimes be easier said than done.

 

During the season, especially late, when tensions and stakes are high, it can be easy to ignore hits to the head so that good players are not being taken out of play. Some players even resist medical check-up during the game and immediately afterwards so that they can continue on the field. Only after the season is over do they then decide that they should have followed up. Make sure that when there is a suspected injury, especially a concussion, that it is assessed and the care plan is followed. You don’t want to be in a position like this one.

 

http://www.athleticbusiness.com/athlete-safety/former-college-athlete-sues-school-over-concussion-protocol.html?topic=2,100&eid=277204494&bid=1092191

 

Right now, concussions are very popular in the media, so any suspected head injury needs to be assessed by a physician before letting a player return. While this can make it hard on coaches, it is a lot easier than getting a lawsuit later. Unfortunately, coaching  has to take legal protection decisions into consideration these days. If you coach, make sure that you understand what you get into: protect your players, yourself and your institution by making sure that you educate all involved and don’t get more involved in wins and losses than player safety. Take the time to assess any injury and listen to medical recommendations regarding your athletes.

Thursday, March 19, 2015

Use of King Devick test in concussions

The King Devick test has been proposed to aid in the assessment of concussions. The test has individuals perform a visual eye scan reading numbers on the card from left to right as quickly and accurately as possible. It has been shown that those who have sustained a concussion have a slower time (about 4-5 seconds) than their non-concussed counterparts. Proponents of the test are urging for its inclusion as part of the sideline examination for those with potential concussions.

 

There have been studies that assess the validity of the test and its sensitivity has been studied in boxing, where laypersons were able to determine who had concussion symptoms from using the test. Another study looked at the amount of information that it added to the current battery of tests being performed on the sideline or in a clinician’s office and found that it did not add any value.

 

The reason that it is gaining popularity among researchers and the media is the ease of use; have someone do the test to get a baseline and then retest them if there is concern for a head injury. The main question I have is what happens with that information? It does not appear that there are any guidelines on what disqualifies someone from activity. The studies have not been extensive enough where there is a clear line separating those with a concussion from those without one. In either case, the recommendation is still to perform a sideline evaluation on them and refer to a qualified medical professional for a diagnosis. While the test may hold promise for laypersons or parents to test their children, caution should definitely be urged against putting too much stock in it. In time, we may have standards recommending the utilization of the test in concussion assessment, but currently, there is not enough information to support its use in athletics.

 

http://www.sportsmedres.org/2015/03/king-devick-test-sideline-concussion-test.html

 

Friday, January 30, 2015

Concussion risk

The NFL posted its injury rates for the 2014 season and there was a drop in the number of concussions.

 

I will not get into the specifics of the article, but what is important to highlight is the fact that the VP of player health and safety said that teams were focusing on ‘heads up tackling’. The number of concussions suffered by players from head to head or shoulder to head was 50% of 2013’s numbers.

 

The take home point for athletes, coaches, fans and athletic trainers is that while concussions will always be a part of the game (and sports in general) it is possible to decrease the risk of injury. By learning proper technique of tackling with the head up, concussion injuries can be decreased.

 

Neurosurgeon’s have now weighed in on their thoughts about concussions and youth sports: the risk of sustaining CTE through sports is far lower than the risk of sustaining heart disease, diabetes and cancer through inactivity.


Proper training, rules and awareness should encourage younger individuals to join team sports, get active and adopt a healthy lifestyle.

 

If your team is not being taught how to tackle appropriately, it is time to speak up. Play safe and have fun. 

 

http://www.athleticbusiness.com/more-news/nfl-reports-significant-drop-in-concussions.html?topic=5,100&eid=277204494&bid=1004478

 

http://www.athleticbusiness.com/athlete-safety/neurologists-weigh-risk-to-kids-of-contact-sports-br.html?topic=4,100&eid=277204494&bid=1004478